Why Good Businesses Often Lose Their Commercial Edge
There is an invisible danger that lurks in the background of all long established and to whatever degree of success a business achieves…
It doesn’t materialise when customers are still buying at a decent level, and when the company is making decent profits!! It lurks in the background because the owner has established a level of comfort with the way the company is moving forward, which is why they don’t see the need to tweak or change things.
And that’s precisely where the problems can begin.
Over time, a successful business develops familiar routines. The owner knows the customers, understands the market and has established methods that have produced good results for many years. Employees know what’s expected of them, suppliers understand the arrangements and the whole organisation operates in a way that feels comfortable.
I call this the velvet rut.
It’s not necessarily a business that’s failing or even one that’s performing badly. It’s just performing ‘well enough’ that nobody is questioning whether the things that made it successful in the past, are still the things that will make it successful in the future.
Meanwhile, the market subtly continues to warp and change over time.
Customers develop different expectations, competitors improve their offerings and new ways of doing business emerge. Costs move, purchasing decisions change and what once gave a company a competitive advantage gradually becomes less important.
The owner often doesn’t realise what’s happening until the financial results deteriorate, by which point the business has already begun to lose ground to its competitors.
Experience is valuable, but it needs to remain relevant
I’ve always placed huge value on practical business experience, particularly the kind gained from making difficult decisions and dealing with the consequences.
There’s no substitute for that knowledge, but it does need to be accompanied by a willingness to question our assumptions.
An owner who’s spent the last twenty or thirty years building a successful company has every reason to be confident in their judgement. The danger comes when that confidence develops into the ‘belief’ that they understand everything important about their market.
A competitor may be approaching customers differently, or the expectations of buyers may be changing. Technology may be making certain processes more efficient, or customers may be placing greater importance on factors that weren’t particularly relevant a few years earlier.
None of those developments automatically mean the business should change direction, but they deserve to be understood.
Good commercial judgement involves recognising which developments matter and which are simply noise.
The owner who dismisses every new approach because the old methods have always worked may eventually discover that the market has moved on without them.
The customers you already have, don’t tell you everything
Established businesses often take considerable comfort from their existing customer relationships, particularly when those relationships have developed over many years.
That’s understandable, because loyal customers are valuable.
But they don’t necessarily provide a complete picture of the marketplace.
A customer who has dealt with your business for the last fifteen years may be perfectly satisfied with the service they receive. That doesn’t tell you why prospective customers are choosing competitors or whether your offering remains attractive to the wider market.
I think owners should pay particular attention to the business they’re not winning.
Why are potential customers choosing somebody else? Is the issue price, service, delivery, technical capability or simply the way the company presents itself?
The answers may be uncomfortable, but they can also reveal opportunities to improve before the existing customer base begins to weaken.
Profitability can conceal a gradual decline
One of the difficulties with losing commercial relevance is that it doesn’t always produce an immediate financial crisis.
The business may continue reporting acceptable profits while margins gradually decline, customer acquisition becomes more expensive or increasingly generous terms are needed to retain important accounts.
Individually, these developments can be explained away.
Together, they may indicate the company’s competitive position is weakening.
This is why I think owners need to look beyond turnover and examine the quality of the profits they’re earning.
Are margins holding up? Is the business having to work harder to maintain the same financial result? Are customers becoming more demanding without paying for the additional service?
Those questions help establish whether the business is genuinely strengthening or simply continuing to operate on the strength of its established reputation.
Management should contribute to commercial awareness
A strong management team has an important role in keeping a business relevant.
If the owner is the only person expected to understand the market, recognise changes and challenge established practices, the company becomes dependent on one individual’s perspective and that is a dangerous thing for any business.
Good managers should understand what’s happening in their areas of responsibility and be prepared to raise concerns when performance or market conditions suggest that something needs attention.
That doesn’t mean encouraging disagreement for its own sake, but there should be enough confidence within the organisation for people to question assumptions and contribute to better decisions.
An owner who only wants reassuring information may find that problems remain hidden until they become considerably more difficult to resolve.
Staying ahead of the game requires regular examination
I’m not suggesting that established businesses should constantly change direction or pursue every new idea that appears.
Some traditional methods remain highly effective, and there is no commercial benefit in abandoning something that continues to work well.
The important thing is understanding why it works and whether the circumstances that made it successful still exist.
I would encourage business owners to regularly examine their competitive position, customer relationships, profitability and the assumptions behind the way they operate.
It’s much easier to make sensible adjustments while the business is performing well than to wait until declining results force a more difficult response.
A successful history is something to be proud of, but it shouldn’t become the reason a business stops improving.
The market doesn’t stand still, and neither should the thinking of the people responsible for running and growing the business.
Found this interesting?: The Kettley Wealth Assessment can provide a structured starting point for examining the commercial quality, market position and longer-term value of your business.
